FixOrReplace
Repair vs replace · proration

Decision

Verdict

—

Enter your repair and replacement numbers to see which path costs less per year.

Waiting on repair cost, repair life, replacement price and new life.

Difference — per year

Repair per year

—

Enter repair cost and repair life.

Replace per year

—

Enter replacement price and new life.

The repair wins if it costs less than $—.

Enter replacement price, repair life and new life.

Check this against your repair quote

Cumulative cost

Repair and keep versus replace now

Repair & keep Replace now

At year —: repair — · replace —.

Enter repair cost, repair life, replacement price and new life to draw both paths.

Model: repair = repair cost + (years owned ÷ repair life) × replacement price; replace = replacement price + (years owned ÷ new life) × replacement price.

Inputs

Your numbers only

Optional. Used in the verdict sentence.

yr
yr
years

How far out to compare. Starts at 10 years; type any horizon you want.